Apostle Keith offers an overview of the Pentecostal movement, which he has been a part of for the last 45 years. highlighting its evolution and characteristics. Initially, the Azusa Street Revival, a foundational event from 1906-1909, featured worship without musical instruments or hymnbooks, emphasizing spontaneous, Spirit-led expression. However, as Pentecostalism grew, musical instruments quickly became central to its lively worship style, drawing from African American spiritual and gospel traditions. The texts also describe a shift in leaders' attire, moving from early Pentecostalism's rejection of formal vestments to a more recent adoption of clerical attire among some Black Pentecostal leaders, driven by denominational structure, influence from traditional churches, and cultural aesthetics. Finally, the sources categorize the movement into three distinct waves: Classical Pentecostals (early 20th century, forming new denominations with a focus on Spirit baptism and tongues), Neo-Pentecostals (1960s-1970s, bringing charismatic experiences into existing mainline churches), and Contemporary/Modern Pentecostals (1980s onward, often independent churches emphasizing spiritual gifts and contemporary worship).
Briefing Document: Nuances of Pentecostalism
Introduction
This briefing document provides an overview of key aspects and historical developments within the Pentecostal movement, drawing from provided sources. It highlights the evolution of worship practices, leadership attire, and the categorization of different waves of Pentecostalism, emphasizing the diversity within this globally significant Christian tradition.
I. Musical Instruments in Pentecostal Worship
Contrary to popular assumption, the earliest Pentecostal gatherings, specifically the Azusa Street Revival (1906-1909), were largely devoid of musical instruments. This a cappella approach was rooted in a profound belief that the Holy Spirit's presence rendered artificial aids unnecessary.
Absence of Instruments: "Initially, there were generally no musical instruments at the Azusa Street Revival meetings." Participants believed "the presence of the Holy Spirit was so profound that no artificial aids like musical instruments were necessary."
Spontaneity: Worship was "spontaneous, often characterized by speaking in tongues, prophetic utterances, and singing 'in the Spirit.'"
No Hymnbooks: "Hymns were sung from memory, often with new, spontaneous melodies or in the 'new song' of the Spirit."
Emphasis on Holy Spirit's Leading: Services were "not pre-planned or highly structured. Everything was meant to be led by the Holy Spirit, which included the music."
First-hand Account: Frank Bartleman, a chronicler of the Azusa Street Revival, noted, "In the beginning in 'Azusa' we had no musical instruments. In fact we felt no need of them. There was no place for them in our worship. All was spontaneous. We did not even sing from hymnbooks."
Despite these early practices, the movement quickly integrated instruments as it expanded, adopting "rhythmic and lively music, drawing heavily on African American spirituals and gospel traditions." This evolution laid the groundwork for the instrument-rich worship characteristic of modern Pentecostalism.
II. Evolution of Leaders' Attire
The adoption of formal "Roman clerical attire" by some Black Pentecostal leaders marks a significant shift from the movement's foundational principles of simplicity and rejection of formalism.
Early Pentecostalism (Early 20th Century): Rejection of Formalism: Early Pentecostalism, including its Black leadership, "largely rejected the elaborate vestments and hierarchical structures of older, established denominations." This was driven by an "emphasis on spiritual spontaneity, direct experience of the Holy Spirit, and a desire to break away from what was perceived as dead ritualism."
Focus on Holiness and Simplicity: "Clergy typically wore everyday suits or simple dresses, distinguishing themselves more by their spiritual fervor than by special attire."
Mid-to-Late 20th Century and Beyond: Gradual Shift: Organizational Development: As Pentecostalism matured and formed large denominations (e.g., Church of God in Christ), there was a "natural move towards greater structure, order, and a more defined clergy. Formal attire can symbolize this established order and authority."
Influence from Mainline Churches: Growth and wider acceptance led some leaders to "adopt elements of liturgical practice and clerical dress from more traditional churches, seeking to convey a sense of legitimacy, dignity, and historical continuity."
Emphasis on Leadership: The rise of powerful leaders within Black Pentecostal traditions "led to an embrace of attire that visually conveyed their office and authority."
African American Cultural Aesthetic: Incorporating formal vestments became a way to "merge this cultural pride and sense of occasion with their Pentecostal faith. The visual splendor could be seen as giving glory to God."
Global Influence: The trend was also influenced by "African Pentecostal-Charismatic Churches in the late 20th century," suggesting a reciprocal exchange of practices.
It is important to note that this adoption is "not universal across all Black Pentecostal churches or denominations," with many maintaining informal dress codes.
III. Different Waves of Pentecostalism
The terms "Classical Pentecostals," "Neo-Pentecostals" (Charismatic Movement), and "Contemporary/Modern Pentecostals" (Neo-Charismatics/Third Wave) differentiate distinct phases and expressions within the broader Pentecostal and Charismatic movements. While sharing core beliefs, they vary in origin, emphasis, and relationship to traditional denominations.
1. Classical Pentecostals
Origin: Emerged in the early 20th century, particularly from the Azusa Street Revival (1906-1909) and the Holiness movement.
Key Distinctive: Belief in the "Baptism with the Holy Spirit as a distinct second work of grace subsequent to conversion, with speaking in tongues (glossolalia) as the initial physical evidence of this experience."
Denominational Affiliation: Formed their own denominations (e.g., Assemblies of God, Church of God in Christ).
Worship Style: "Vibrant, often spontaneous worship, strong emphasis on divine healing, evangelism, and a sometimes more 'otherworldly' or separatist stance from mainstream culture."
2. Neo-Pentecostals (Charismatic Movement)
Origin: Emerged primarily in the 1960s and 1970s as a "renewal movement" within existing mainline Protestant denominations and even the Roman Catholic Church.
Key Distinctive: Did not leave their traditional denominations. "The Baptism of the Holy Spirit was often viewed as an empowering experience available to all believers, not necessarily always tied to tongues as the initial physical evidence."
Denominational Affiliation: Remained within established denominations, forming "charismatic fellowships."
Worship Style: "While incorporating charismatic elements, their worship could sometimes be more structured than classical Pentecostalism, often blending traditional liturgy with spontaneous praise."
3. Contemporary / Modern Pentecostals (Neo-Charismatics or "Third Wave")
Origin: Arose from the 1980s onward, characterized by independent, non-denominational churches (e.g., Vineyard Movement, Calvary Chapel, mega-churches).
Key Distinctive: Embrace miraculous gifts but "may not explicitly teach the 'Baptism with the Holy Spirit as a second work of grace with tongues as initial evidence' as a foundational theological distinctive." They see Spirit's empowerment as a continuous aspect of Christian life.
Denominational Affiliation: Operate as independent churches or networks, often avoiding traditional denominational structures.
Worship Style: "Very contemporary worship music (often 'praise and worship' style), casual dress, less formal liturgy, and a strong emphasis on evangelism, social engagement, and often 'power evangelism' (demonstrating God's power through signs and wonders)."
These categories, also recognized by Apostle Keith Jenkins, help understand the movement's historical development, though overlap exists, and diversification continues.
Share this post